Sleeping Beauty II – I smell a sequel

by Amy Rensberger

Most modern consumers of fairy tales who recount the story of Sleeping Beauty will end it when the prince wakes her up from her 100-year slumber. The second half of the story is very rarely told. When I read Charles Perrault's version on SurLaLune Fairy Tales, I awoke from a near 40-year slumber, as the cobwebs in my memory of fairy tale classics began to clear.
For those of you who haven't brushed up on the original, an intriguing shift of perspective takes place, away from the accursed princess and her family's woes. Instead, the tale focuses squarely on the prince and his own familial baggage.
First he keeps his marriage to his strange bride a secret, fearing the wrath of his human-eating mother - who is described as a descendant of Ogres. Then, when the prince's father dies and Princey becomes king, he reveals his bride and children amidst celebration, only to leave her and his kids in his mother's care while he goes off to war with a neighboring Emperor.
Within a few days, Queen Beauty's crazy mother-in-law had decided to eat two of her grandchildren, Morning and Day, and ordered they be prepared by the kitchen clerk. The clerk, thankfully, could not kill the children, instead hiding them and serving a tasty lamb instead of Morning. Granny was tricked, but later requested the 3-year-old, Day, to be served in the same Sauce Robert. This time the cook served up a kid goat, and Gran was again fooled.
But the new king's mother wasn't sated until she ate Queen Beauty, and requested that meal as well. The poor queen, thinking her children were dead, was willing to go under the knife, but the cook reunited the mother and children and hid them all, serving a three-year-old deer called a hind instead.
Unfortunately, for the immediate royal family, the Queen Mother caught wind of the trickery. This occurred when strolling the grounds and hearing the children's crying -- Day had been whipped for being naughty. So she ordered up a cauldron of serpents, vipers, and toads to be placed in the middle of the court. The deceivers were about to be tossed in, when in rides the King, who is dumbfounded at what he encounters. “ [He] asked, with the utmost astonishment, what was the meaning of this horrible spectacle.”
His mother, outraged to be challenged, goes into the ultimate martyrdom act, throwing herself into the cauldron. “The King could not but be very sorry, for she was his mother; but he soon comforted himself with his beautiful wife and his pretty children.”
Ah, what a lost classic this second half of Sleeping Beauty is. I can't help but think of the first narrator of the story, perhaps a young mother telling this tale to her children. She manages to work in the fact that bratty kids get their comeuppance, first when Beauty grabs the spindle without so much as an “if you please” and then when Beauty's child Day cries during his punishment.
But what is much more fun is when our narrator takes out her frustrations of her mother-in-law and husband in a dark and dismal depiction of apathy by the husband, as well as a struggle for power between the two women Royals. I particularly like how the prince appears as a mama's boy, overly engrossed in his job and clueless to the folly of leaving his wife and children in the hands of his mother.
Given that we are in a feminist age, where men are typically depicted in a manner much like this story, I can't help but wonder how this section of the tale became lost – could it be a 1950s Disney conspiracy?
More importantly, who will be the one to revive “Sleeping Beauty: The Sequel“ for the modern age? Excuse me, I've got to go call Oprah's and Drew Barrymore's production companies. Time to start a bidding war.

6

8 comments:

The Ink Gypsy said...

I was only able to leave 1 'interesting' on the page but wanted to thank both Kaitlin and Amy for their pieces.

The poem is wonderful (I'd love a copy of this, although I can't decide if I'd gift it to the sons, the brides to be or the mother-in-laws to be!)

And the article is great. I agree this part of the story could really use some more attention and is perfect for today. You know you might actually have some luck with Drew's Prod. Company... ;)

Maria said...

What a treat! A bit of fairydust mixed with Silence of the Lambs! I love how the article focuses on the evil mother in law. Makes me look at mine in a whole new light! I'd love to see this part of the tale in a book. Maybe you should write a book of Fairytales entitled 'What Happened Next'. I'd buy it for sure. The piece is very well written and I enjoyed it immensely.

Anonymous said...

What a great poem. As someone who has suffered through a mother-in-law with issues, I can totally relate. As someone who has grown up with only one version (Disney’s) of Sleeping beauty I have to say I was shocked by the second half of this story. I am used to the innocent children’s movie with the beautiful Briar Rose, the majestic parents, the gorgeous prince, and the adorable fairies. However, I have to see I am pleasantly surprised. I am sure it has to do something with my twisted sense of humor, but I would love to read the second half of this tale. As I was reading the article describing the second half of Perrault's story I was thinking how typical it was for a male to know the issues his mother has then nonchalantly take off and assume everything will be just fine. I love your quote about the Prince being a mama’s boy engrossed in his work and clueless. He knows his mother is completely dangerous and has a craving for humans, yet he exposes his wife and young children to her anyway. I thought MY husband was in denial about his mother! It is amazing that this many years later some things will never change.

Rasonda
T390

Coinilius said...

I had the same feeling of revelation when I first encountered the 'lost' second half of the Sleeping Beauty story a few years ago. Having been raised on the usual, 'Prince wakes Sleeping Beauty and they all live happily ever after' point that modern versions of the story seem fit to stop at, to suddenly come across ogres and baby eating and cauldrons full of serpents - the mind boggled at what had been left out of the story for so long!

I'd pay to see Disney takle this as one of their video only sequels! Ok, so that's out of the question, but some more interest in the complete version of the Sleeping Beauty tale would certainly be welcome...

Anonymous said...

Wow this story took me into a total shock, growing up my entire life only know Disney’s Sleeping Beauty I never even thought that there could be a second edition to the story especially being a story like this. The ending of this story to me was totally shocking, I have heard from many people that mother-in-laws are mean and scary but to eat the grandchildren I could never imagine. As a parent of a three year old daughter the thought of getting married to a man whose mother would even consider enjoying us as a dinner treat would be unbearable, the entire thought is disgusting! What would make someone even think about a story like this; I think it is a good thing that I never heard this second part of the story because I don’t know what I would think of it as a young child. As a child I am sure that I would have probably had nightmares for weeks after hearing this story.
K.A.

gleyba said...

The untold part to “Sleeping Beauty” is definitely a shocker, but then again basically every original fairy tale is having such an effect on me. It is interesting that this part is often left out. Maybe it is some sort of Disney conspiracy trying to ensure that everyone lives happily ever after once the princess gets her prince. Or possibly it has to do with its greater focus on the prince. Despite the appeal of Prince Charming, men in fairy tales are not very popular. It could just be that people were not interested in the prince’s story and so just left it with the typical happily ever after scene. I do enjoy the second part’s family issues with Beauty’s monster-in-law. The conflict between brides and their mother-in-laws definitely still applies today as the lovely poem above denotes. Of course the Ogress must have desires to eat her and her children. I’m starting to think that a fairy tale cannot be a fairy tale without someone trying to eat somebody!
G.Leyba

Kenny Holmes said...

I can see it now in the neon highlights, and blinking lights, that are all in black and white, “Sleeping Beauty 2: Revenge of the Nasty Mother.” The imagery that accompanies my image of this saga in the movie theatre is another Walt Disney Production set in the 1950’s. Awesome old vehicles line the black and white street, where the spotlights are dancing over the movie theater. Walt Disney, himself, is there for the opening event of a movie that he was so against because he wanted to keep his movies soft and family friendly, and not worry about having to deal with the general public where the people are upset because he has been less than appropriate, according to family values of the day. But the movie will be in excellent Disney characterization and play the Ogre-ish eating of the mothers love for the uncanny supposal of the Queen Beauty.

Who are we kidding this would make a horrible movie…

Anonymous said...

I find it quite interesting that the graphic depiction in this scary tale is not often talked about when considering the role of the prince and his family. We spend so much time talking about the female character's troubles and concerns that the family of the prince, or the prince himself, rarely receive more than a few seconds or reaction time, let alone contemplate what his presence really signifies. The fact that the prince’s mother is a flesh eating ogre just might have a little something to do with the prince being uneasy with leaving his children with their dear old grand-mother. For certain it is bad judgment on his part when he, against previous reasoning’s, goes ahead and leaves the children with their meat eating grandmother. If the idea of living happily ever after came from fairy tales originally, I assure you that I am unsure as to why. The character’s rarely meet with a truly happy ending in the original versions of the fairy tales.

Labels

"Beauty and the Old Maid (1) 50 to 1 (1) A Fanciful Twist (1) A Father's Weakness (1) A Modern Tale of Today's Young Bell (1) A Royal Awakening (1) A Servant's Tale (1) About Roses (1) Affective Disenchantment (1) Aisling Burke (3) Alexandra Seidel (2) Alexandrea Seidel (1) Allerleirauh (1) Allison Hunter-Frederick (1) Amanda C. Davis (2) Amanda Marlowe (4) Amy Rensberger (2) And So (1) and Tahlia (1) and the Flowers (1) Anna Marie Catoir (1) apathy (4) Ariel Woodruff (4) Armless Maiden (1) Art Magick (1) artists (1) Ashley Veemuri (1) authors (1) Avil Beckford (2) Awake to Fate (2) Basile (1) Beastly (1) Beauty and Beast Comment Winner (2) Beauty and the Beast (25) Beauty and the Beast Feast (1) Beauty and the Beast have a daughter (1) Beauty and the Beast writing contest winner (2) Beauty and the Beast writing contests (3) Beauty and the Book Reviews (1) Beauty Awakens (1) Beauty Haunts the Beast (1) Before the Dawn (1) Ben Langhinrichs (4) Ben Loory (2) Beyond the Happy Ending (1) Bigfoot (1) Black Sheep (2) Blog Commment Contest (2) Blogger Beta Trouble (1) Bonita and the Hacienda (1) Bonus Story in Enchanted Conversation (1) Breanna Teintze (2) Briar and Rose Enchanted Conversation (2) Brittany Roshelle Davis (1) Broken (1) By Heather Talty (1) Call for submissions (1) Cameron Dokey (1) Cathy C. Hall (2) Cathy McGuire (1) Cecelia Myers (5) Christina Rossetti (1) Cinderella writing contest (1) Claire Massey (3) Contest Promotion Winner (1) contributors (1) Cooking Children With Witch Wanda (1) Cosmos Online (1) curses (1) D.L. Ashliman (1) Deadline (1) Debbie Cowens (1) Deborah walker (4) Diamondsandtoads.com (1) DL Ashliman (1) Dog-Ear Tales (1) Dorlana Vann (1) Easter Christopher (1) EC Mermaid Issue Contest (1) EC writing contest (1) Edward Frederick Brewton (1) Eisenkopf (1) Elizabeth Creith (1) Em D'Sylvia (1) Emily Balivet (1) Encha (1) Enchanted Conversation (35) Enchanted Conversation has moved (1) Enchanted Conversation Volume One Issue Four (1) Eric Pazdziora (1) Erik Tracy (1) Eternity (1) Ethna (1) Etsy (3) Eva Eliav (3) Expectations (1) Eyes As Blue As Cornflowers (1) Fairy In Stilettos (1) fairy tale blogs (1) Fairy Tale Contest (1) fairy tale controversy (1) Fairy Tale Food (3) fairy tale magazine (12) fairy tale retellings (1) fairy tales (2) Farida Dowler (1) Finding Beauty (2) First Queen's Maid (1) Foam on the Sea (1) Frances MacNair (1) Francesca Lia Block (1) Geese (1) Gerri Leen (5) Goblin Market (1) goblins (1) Grimms (1) Gustave Dore (1) Gypsy Thornton (2) Hanse (1) Hansel and Gretel Duck Contest winners (3) Hansel and Gretel Issue (10) Happily Ever After (3) Henry Meynell Rheam (1) Her Father's Tale (1) His Soul's Inspiration (1) Home Again (1) Home Again Jiggety-Jig (1) Home to the Sea (1) I am A Beast (1) Inner Smile (1) Into the Forest and Through the Woods (1) Issue Four (1) J.A. Grimshaw (1) J.W. Waterhouse (1) Jack Nemo (1) Jacqueline West (1) Janet Bucklew (2) Jazz Sexton (1) Jennifer Liu (2) Jennifer Povey (2) Jim Baen's Universe (1) John Anster Fitzgerald (1) John C. Mannone (2) John Collier (1) John Patrick Pazdziora (3) John R. Neill (1) John Roddam Spencer-Stanhope (1) Jude Tulli (4) Juleigh Howard-Hobson (1) Just In Case (1) K. Curran Mayer (1) Kaitlin Stahl (3) Kaliedotrope (1) Katie Lovett (2) Katrina Robinson (1) Kay Nielsen (1) Keyan Bowes (1) Knives Then Foam (1) Lamentation for a Little Mermaid (1) Laura Garrison (3) Layout Trouble (1) Like Flies on the Wall (1) Linda (1) Little Brier-Rose (1) Little Hans (1) Little mermaid (1) Lory Widmer Hess (1) Lucia's Wish (1) Lynnette Wissink (2) Madame T's (1) Magic Kiss (1) Manley and the Missing Link (1) Marcus Stone Sleeping Beauty Writing Contest winners (1) Margaret Evans Price (1) Maria Duffy (3) Marie Croke (1) Marine Warner (1) market for fairy tale writers (1) Martin Willitts Jr (1) Megan Arkenberg (1) Melisande (1) Melusina (1) Membrane 12 (1) Mermaid Contest Winners (3) Mermaid Issue (2) Mermaid Menu. Claire Massey (1) Mermaids (1) Micro-Horror (1) Mike Berger (2) Mirror Dance (1) Moon (1) Nennillo and Nennella (1) new address for Enchanted Conversation (1) new post on fairy tale retelling zine (1) New writing market (1) New Zealand (1) Nikki Hall (4) Norton Hint Fiction Anthology (1) Oceane (1) ogres (1) Olivia Arieti (1) Once Upon A Blog (1) Online Fairy Tale Journal (1) Ophelia's Remembrance (1) Outcast's Tale (1) Paul McCloskey (2) Prince of Dreams (2) Pushcart Prize nominee (1) Robin McKinley (1) Roses on Snow (2) Rossetti Couture (1) Rotten Leaves Magazine (1) Sacred Texts (1) Samuel Valentino (4) Sarah Stasik (1) Sauce Robert (1) Scullery Boy Remembers (1) Seashell (1) Shannon Anthony (1) She Smiled (1) Sisterhood (1) Sleeping Beauty (13) Sleeping Beauty Unplugged (1) Sleeping Beauty Writing Contest (2) Sleeping Beauty Writing Contest winners (2) Sleeping Beauty's Dream (1) spindle (1) Staff Members (1) Steampunk (1) Stella Jones (1) Sugar Cotaed Dreams (1) Sugarcoated (1) Sun (1) Table of Contents (4) Tahlia Merrill (5) Tales from the Moonlit Path (1) Teardrops (1) teen writing contest (1) The Blackpool Mermaid (2) The Blacksmith's Children (1) The Bride (2) The Diary of Beauty's Sister (1) The Enchanted Pig (1) The Fairy Speaks (1) The First Queen's Maid (1) The Fisherman's Tale (1) The Fleetness of Love (1) The Graphics Fairy (1) The Guardian (2) The Little Mermaid (2) The Little Mermaid's Secret Song (2) The Little Mermaid: A Lesson for Women (1) The Lost Mermaid (1) The Mermaid and the Stag (1) The Mermaid's Eldest Sister (1) The New Yorker (1) The Nixy (2) The Not-So-Little Mermaid (1) The Problem With Fairy Tales (1) The Rogue Rose (1) The Rose Deflowered (1) The Rosebud That Didn't Want to Bloom (1) The Schwarzwald Incident (1) The Sea Calls To Them All (1) The Sea Witch (1) The Sea Witch's Daughter (1) The Sea Witch's Tale (1) The Sideshow (1) The Sisters of the Sea (1) The Sleeping Beauty (1) The Stars Would Sing (1) The Trouble With Candy Houses (1) the Vase (1) The White Bird (1) The Woman (1) The Young Bride's Dream (1) Thea Hutcheson (1) Their Daughter Rose (1) Theresa Blake (1) Things That Cannot Be Eaten (1) Tiger In the Matchstick Box (1) To Dance on Swords (1) Torn (1) Twelth Fairy Confesses (1) Twisted Dreams (1) Twisted Legends (1) Two Sides To Every Story (1) V Magazine for Women (1) Valerie Koines Anderson (1) Volume One/Issue Two (1) Waking Belinda (1) What Wondrous Spells (2) Writing Contest for Hansel and Gretel (2) writing contests (9) www.EnchantedConversation.org (1) Wynne Huddleston (5) Yeti (1)